« 25 years ago today | Main | Sinn Fein recognises the importance of education »

The Foundations of Sand of the IPCC CO2 Historic Records

I have been kindly sent Ernst Beck's Summary of his Paper - please note updated supplementing webpage giving new and further information concerning the actual paper. http://www.biokurs.de/treibhaus/180CO2_supp.htm. It is explosive in its implications.


180 Years of atmospheric CO2 Gas Analysis by Chemical Methods

StD Ernst-Georg Beck Dipl. Biol.; ENERGY & ENVIRONMENT; VOLUME 18 No. 2, 2007


The Greatest Scandal in Modern History of Science

7 essential findings of the study in pictures:

Copyright E&E 2007and egb; all rights reserved

1. CO2 is an essential, natural substance for man, all animals and plants.

image001.jpg


2. Climate science (UN) “permits” only the following variations in CO2 content of air. The left picture is erroneous.

image002.jpg

3. There is no need to invent an AGW (greenhouse effect by man) for explaining warmth in 20th century.

image004.jpg

4. The study is able to prove that responsible scientists Callendar and Keeling ignored scientific literature.

 

 

Year

Authors

Cited authors and papers with data

Notes

 

 

Total

19 th c.

20thc.

 

1900

Letts and Blake [14]

252

252

-

only 19th century (+)

1912

Benedict [15]

137

137

-

+; focus on O2-determination

1940

Callendar [16]

13

7

6

cited Letts&Blake and Benedict

1951

Effenberger [17]

56

32

24

cited Duerst1, Misra1 and Kreutz1

1952

Stepanova [18]

229

130

99

citation as Effenberger

1956

Slocum [19]

33

22

11

cited Duerst and Kreutz

1958

Callendar [20]

30

18

12

no citing of Duerst, Kreutz and Misra

1958

Bray [21]

49

20

19

cited most important through the centuries

1986

Fraser [22]

6

6

-

+, same as Callendar

1986

Keeling [23 ]

18

18

-

+, same as Callendar;

2006

Beck [this study]

156

82

74

only chemical determination until 1961

Bibliographies and citation of papers


5. The study is able to prove that the responsible scientists Callendar and Keeling praised wrong historic data as true.

image006.jpg
6. UN published a distorted view of history of natural science and postulated that there were no accurate measurements prior to 1958. This study is able to prove that there are more than 90 000 direct accurate measurements of CO2 used to reconstruct the real CO2 contour over the last 200 years.
image008.jpg


CO2 fluctuates following climate and in former times there are much higher concentrations compared to today (e.g. around 1820, 1857 and 1942). The assertion of UN of a pre-industrial CO2 concentration of 294 ppm is wrong. In 19th century average CO2 concentration was 341 ppm compared to modern 380 ppm. (ppm = Parts per Million)

7. CO2 amount in air varies monthly with lunar phases as ocean tides.
image010.jpg

Conclusions:

CO2 follows climate
CO2 was also high in former times
CO2 is not responsible for current warming
Ice core records used by UN are not sensible enough to resolve short-time CO2 variations

To be done:
CO2 reconstructions from ice core records have to be revised
Carbon flux models have to be revised for “fast” CO2 emission out of oceans


Download this entry as a word document with high quality graphics and formatting.


Comments

Mr Beck conveniently left out the range of the data in the 1940's which is typically hundreds of ppms. This indicates that the source of the co2 is local and not representative for global background. Which was already argued by Fonselius, who earmarked the data of Duerst, Kreutz and Misra specifically as outliers.

http://www.someareboojums.org/blog/?p=25

Quito may 08th,2008

Dear mrs/mr


The Farm Huasillama, comprising 23400 hectares is found by the volcano Cotopaxi, occupying part of the provinces of Cotopaxi, Pichincha and Napo in Ecuador.
There is an increasing need to both maintain and create carbon reservoirs as a way of dealing with the constant emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) into the atmosphere due to the combustion of fuels and detrimental deforestation practices. Various options are available to face this challenge, one of witch is the creation of MDL projects (Development of Cleaning Mechanisme) under the Kyoto Protocol regulations; these would be in charge of collecting the CO2 produced by industrial and human processes instead of it being release to the atmosphere.
During the past 10 years,we have been developing the Huasillama Project, and it has been classified as a collector of CO2 by several studies performed by different companies and other specialized organizations, such as, ECOPAR, CEDARENA, THE FOREST AND BIRD SOCIETY, among many others. These have concluded that the Huasillama farm has around 2.300.000 tons of carbon, which translate into approximately 8.400.000 tons of carbon dioxide.
The unit for carbon dioxide trade is known as CER ( Certificate Emission Reduction) and these are the documents that can be negotiated in the stock markets worldwide or are bought directly by companies that contaminate and thus must compensate for these emissions by paying fines or taxes to their respective governments through the acquisition of the CER’s. These documents are issued by “Empresas Verifacadores”, such as Bureau Veritas, SGS and others amd the price per measured certified ton in the international market, especially in Europe and Asia , fluctuates between 20 and 25 USD.
Currently the Huasillama Project is emitting CER’s together with the international “Verificadora” Bureau Veritas, and this phase will take approximately 180 days from the date the contract is signed.
The promoters of the project are interested in finding strategic and financial partners or companies who are interested to buy the project to be able to proceed ; additionally, other projects can be developed in the farm , which include ecotourism, bottling of natural spring water, production of alpaca fiber to manufacture fabrics, commercialization of the same camelids and others.

If you have any further concerns or questions please do not hesitate to contact me .

Raymond van Aken
Telf: 00593-2 2263762
Cel: 00593- 96061070
E-mail : overzee@espoltel.net.ec

Post a comment