« No man but a blockhead ever wrote, except for money | Main | Evidence Based Policies »

Nanny On The Naughty Step Please

Warning: the nanny state can seriously improve your health - Health News, Health & Families - The Independent
The "nanny state" mostly gets a pasting from critics who dismiss government efforts to make us fitter or slimmer or healthier as unwarranted intrusion into individual's lives.
Today, the critics get their comeuppance with research showing that nannying works. In the first year after the smoking ban was introduced in July 2007, the air in bars, restaurants and offices suddenly became sweeter – and more than 1,000 heart attacks were prevented.
Researchers, from the University of Bath, who examined hospital statistics for England found there were 1,200 fewer admissions for heart attacks in the 12 months after the introduction of the smoke-free law.

Yaa Boo Sucks - Nanny was right, how could any one argue against her? And her new plans for more restrictions.

Just look at the figures!

England%20AMI%20-%20gilmore.jpg


Emergency AMI admissions in English hospitals

2002/03: 61,498
2003/04: 60,680 (a fall of 1.33%)
2004/05: 58,803 (a fall of 3.1%)
2005/06: 55,752 (a fall of 5.19%)
2006/07: 53,964 (a fall of 3.21%)
2007/08: 51,664 (a fall of 4.26%)

As you can see, the decline in admissions in the year after the smoking ban was larger than the year before but smaller than the year before that. In fact, the average in the previous two years was 4.2%—almost exactly what it was in the year after the ban (4.26%).

Faced with this evidence, from a nation of 49 million people, what else can you do but hold up your hands and admit that smoking bans have no perceivable effect on a nation's heart attack rate?

So what's Gilmore's conclusion?

We therefore conclude that the implementation of smoke-free public places is associated with significant reductions in hospital admissions for myocardial infarction

Huh?

Comments

Come on Tim, he is right. It is also associated with NO smoking ban as well.

The truth, but not the WHOLE truth. Worthy of Fondlebum of Boys himself.

Alan Douglas

Come on Tim, he is right. It is also associated with NO smoking ban as well.

The truth, but not the WHOLE truth. Worthy of Fondlebum of Boys himself.

Alan Douglas

So you got lies from a man whose continued access to the trough is dependent on making it look like he has a use.

Same old, same old.

BoyGeorge needs to wield his axe in this general direction I think.

Post a comment