« Google Censors Or SEO Failure | Main | Al Gore's Day Of Action On Climate Reality - The Video »

White Elephants To Power Scotland

SNP warned of 'white elephant' power plan - Scotsman.com News

THE Scottish Government has placed its ambition to transform the nation into a low-carbon economy at the heart of its new strategy for growth.
But experts have warned the commitment to creating a renewable energy powerhouse could be a "white elephant" and that millions of pounds in subsidies pouring into the sector are unjustified

r Euan Mearns, an energy expert at Aberdeen University's school of geosciences, said: "On the one hand we've got to say that we're in favour renewable energy and it would be wonderful if Scotland was a leader in it – but we may end up a world leader in a white elephant.

"The full cost of large reliance on renewable energy needs to be taken fully into account.

"That includes the cost of maintaining back-up power supplies, building new storage and new inter-connectivity, in addition to the building and maintenance of a vast new renewable energy infrastructure.

"Care needs to be taken that the dream doesn't turn into a nightmare should Scotland end up with an unreliable grid. If we end with an unreliable grid, then companies are going to go south of the Border."

And what about the poor bloody consumers cowering in their crofts with only a bowl of porage to keep them warm...

Comments

"And what about the poor bloody consumers cowering in their crofts with only a bowl of porage to keep them warm..."

It will never happen, especially considering their hugh reserves of wind power...

Poor man, pissing against the wind with logic and intelligence, when the religious zealots of green are blowing hard.

"Care needs to be taken that the dream doesn't turn into a nightmare should Scotland end up with an unreliable grid. If we end with an unreliable grid, then companies are going to go south of the Border."

But...

Last week I read an article that started with news that one "renewable" plant was planning to store energy for off-production times by heating a store of salt. Fair enough. Then it went on for pages about how good solar and wind power are - uh... The kicker, to ,e. came around page three, where the author admitted (he would just say "stated" but I prefer "admitted") conventional (cosl, gas, oil, or even nuclear) backup, at 90-100 percent equivalent output, is needed. To him, that was no problem as "these already exist". This is the universe in which these proponents live.

The Scottish government want to have a low carbon nation. Very commendable. Why however do they constantly bang on about 'oor oil'? After all, oil's not exactly low carbon is it?

If you don't mind me making a shameless plug, TPA Director, Matthew Sinclair's book 'Let them eat Carbon' makes an excellent read. http://www.amazon.co.uk/Let-Them-Eat-Carbon-Governments/dp/1849541167

Post a comment